Plot Summary
A Single Day in New York City
Nicola Yoon's "The Sun Is Also a Star" unfolds over the course of a single transformative day in New York City, November 1st, following two teenagers whose lives intersect in the most unlikely circumstances. The novel employs a dual narrative structure, alternating between the perspectives of Natasha Kingsley, a pragmatic seventeen-year-old facing deportation, and Daniel Bae, a romantic Korean-American student torn between his family's expectations and his own dreams.
The story begins with Natasha, a Jamaican-American girl living in Brooklyn, preparing for what she believes will be her family's final day in the United States. Her father's expired visa means the entire family faces deportation to Jamaica, a country Natasha barely remembers and doesn't consider home. As a firm believer in science and rational thinking, Natasha approaches this crisis with characteristic pragmatism, spending her last day attempting to find legal help through an immigration lawyer in Manhattan. She refuses to indulge in sentimentality or false hope, instead focusing on concrete actions that might save her family.
Meanwhile, Daniel begins his day reluctantly heading to an alumni interview for Yale University, a path his Korean immigrant parents have meticulously planned for his future. Despite his parents' dreams of him becoming a doctor, Daniel harbors secret ambitions of becoming a poet. The weight of his family's sacrifices and expectations creates an internal conflict that has defined much of his adolescence. His parents, who own a struggling hair salon, have invested everything in the belief that their son's success will justify their difficult journey to America.
The pivotal moment occurs when these two worlds collide on a busy Manhattan street. As Natasha crosses the road while distracted by her phone, she steps directly into traffic. Daniel, happening to be nearby, pulls her to safety, preventing what could have been a tragic accident. This moment of rescue becomes the catalyst for an extraordinary day that will challenge both characters' fundamental beliefs about love, fate, and the nature of human connection.
The Science of First Contact
Following their dramatic first meeting, Daniel is immediately smitten with Natasha, while she remains skeptical and focused on her immigration appointment. Daniel's romantic nature contrasts sharply with Natasha's scientific mindset, creating a compelling dynamic that drives much of the novel's central tension. Despite Natasha's initial resistance, Daniel convinces her to spend a few hours with him before her lawyer meeting, setting the stage for an intensive exploration of connection and compatibility.
Their afternoon together takes them through various iconic New York locations, from the steps of the Metropolitan Museum of Art to a Korean karaoke restaurant in Koreatown. During these encounters, Yoon skillfully reveals the depth of both characters through their conversations and interactions. Daniel shares his love of poetry and his struggle with family expectations, while Natasha opens up about her scientific worldview and her fear of being torn away from the only home she's ever truly known.
One of the most significant aspects of their day together involves Daniel's attempt to make Natasha fall in love with him using a scientific study about accelerating intimacy. The study involves asking increasingly personal questions designed to create emotional vulnerability and connection. This approach appeals to Natasha's scientific nature while simultaneously challenging her resistance to emotional attachment. Through this exercise, both characters reveal intimate details about their lives, fears, and dreams.
"Maybe part of falling in love with someone else is also falling in love with yourself."
As they move through the city, their initial skepticism toward each other gradually transforms into genuine understanding and attraction. Natasha begins to question her rigid adherence to logic, while Daniel finds someone who challenges his romantic idealism with practical wisdom. Their conversations reveal the complexity of the immigrant experience, exploring themes of belonging, identity, and the sacrifices families make for the promise of a better life.
Family Expectations and Cultural Identity
The novel deeply explores the immigrant experience through both families' stories, revealing how cultural expectations and economic pressures shape the characters' choices. Daniel's parents, particularly his father, represent the traditional Korean emphasis on education and professional success as pathways to American acceptance and prosperity. His father's disappointment in Daniel's artistic inclinations reflects a broader generational conflict about assimilation and the preservation of cultural values.
During a tense family dinner sequence, Daniel's internal struggle becomes external when he finally confronts his parents about his true aspirations. His father's reaction reveals the deep-seated fears and sacrifices that drive immigrant parents to push their children toward certain types of success. The conversation illuminates how parental love can sometimes manifest as pressure, and how children of immigrants often carry the weight of their families' dreams alongside their own.
Natasha's family situation presents a different aspect of the immigrant experience – the constant fear of deportation and the reality that legal status can determine one's entire future. Her father's mistake with visa paperwork represents how small bureaucratic errors can have devastating consequences for immigrant families. The novel shows how this uncertainty affects every member of the family differently, from her father's guilt and depression to her mother's quiet resignation and her brother's angry rebellion.
Through Natasha's eyes, readers experience the frustration of being considered a foreigner in the country she considers home. Her scientific mind rebels against the arbitrary nature of immigration law, where accidents of birth and bureaucratic timing can determine life outcomes. This perspective adds urgency to her growing connection with Daniel, as every moment together is shadowed by the knowledge that their time is limited by forces beyond their control.
The Immigration Crisis and Last-Chance Solutions
The urgency of Natasha's deportation deadline drives the novel's momentum, creating a race-against-time atmosphere that intensifies every interaction. Her appointment with immigration lawyer Jeremy Fitzgerald represents her family's last hope for remaining in the United States legally. The portrayal of this legal consultation reveals the often impersonal nature of immigration proceedings, where individual human stories become reduced to case numbers and procedural requirements.
Fitzgerald's initial assessment is discouraging, as he explains the limited options available to families in Natasha's situation. The legal system's complexity and the arbitrary nature of some immigration decisions become clear as he outlines the various factors that could influence their case. However, a small glimmer of hope emerges when he agrees to make some phone calls and explore last-minute possibilities, though he cautions that the chances of success remain slim.
While waiting for news from the lawyer, Natasha and Daniel continue their exploration of the city and each other. Their conversations become increasingly intimate as they share their deepest fears and hopes. Daniel's persistent optimism begins to influence Natasha's pragmatic outlook, while her grounded perspective helps him see beyond romantic idealization to genuine human connection.
The novel introduces several secondary characters whose lives intersect with the main narrative, demonstrating how individual actions ripple outward to affect others in unexpected ways. These interconnected stories reinforce the book's themes about fate, choice, and the hidden connections that bind people together. From the security guard who lets them into a closed museum exhibit to the coffee shop worker whose small kindness brightens their day, each interaction contributes to the larger tapestry of their experience.
Love and Scientific Skepticism
As the day progresses, Natasha finds herself increasingly drawn to Daniel despite her intellectual resistance to the concept of love at first sight. Her scientific training has taught her to view love as merely chemical reactions and evolutionary imperatives, but her growing feelings for Daniel challenge this reductive interpretation. The novel explores the tension between rational understanding and emotional experience, questioning whether scientific knowledge diminishes or enhances the beauty of human connection.
Daniel's approach to love is equally complex, though from the opposite direction. His romantic nature leads him to believe in destiny and soulmates, but his conversations with Natasha force him to examine whether his feelings are based on genuine compatibility or merely wishful thinking. Their discussions about love, science, and fate reveal how both perspectives – romantic and scientific – can be simultaneously true and limiting.
The famous "36 Questions That Lead to Love" experiment becomes a central element of their connection, providing structure for their emotional intimacy while also serving as a metaphor for the novel's exploration of how people truly come to know each other. Through these questions, both characters reveal vulnerabilities and experiences that have shaped their worldviews, creating the foundation for genuine understanding beyond initial attraction.
"I want to tell her that I can't pull my eyes away from her mouth when she speaks, and that when she laughs, my heart beats so hard against my ribs that I'm sure it's going to break free and fly around the room like a trapped bird."
Their growing connection is tested by the reality of Natasha's situation and the apparent impossibility of their relationship having a future. This temporal limitation forces both characters to confront what love means when it cannot lead to a traditional relationship, and whether meaningful connection can exist independently of longevity or conventional outcomes.
Revelations and Consequences
As evening approaches, several crucial revelations emerge that complicate the narrative and challenge the characters' understanding of their situation. The most significant involves the discovery of connections between their families that neither Daniel nor Natasha could have anticipated. These revelations force both characters to grapple with concepts of fate, coincidence, and the complex ways that individual lives intersect across time and space.
Daniel's father's role in Natasha's family's immigration troubles creates a devastating irony that threatens to destroy the connection they've built throughout the day. This discovery forces both characters to confront how the actions of previous generations can impact present relationships, and whether love can survive the weight of family history and conflicting loyalties.
The revelation also serves as a broader metaphor for the interconnectedness of immigrant communities and the way that individual actions can have far-reaching consequences. It highlights how families struggling for success in a new country sometimes find themselves in competition with others facing similar challenges, creating complex moral situations where there are no clear villains or heroes.
Natasha's reaction to this news tests her growing feelings for Daniel and forces her to choose between personal happiness and family loyalty. The discovery complicates her scientific worldview by presenting a situation where emotion and logic seem to demand different responses. This internal conflict represents the novel's broader exploration of how people navigate situations where rational analysis and emotional truth appear to be in opposition.
Final Hours and Life-Changing Decisions
The novel's climax occurs as the deadline for Natasha's deportation approaches and both characters must decide how to respond to the revelations about their families' interconnected histories. The final hours of their day together are marked by emotional intensity as they struggle to reconcile their feelings for each other with the complex realities of their situation.
Daniel's confrontation with his father about the family's role in Natasha's deportation becomes a pivotal moment for his character development. For the first time, he directly challenges his father's decisions and asserts his own moral judgment, marking his transition from dutiful son to independent young adult. This confrontation also forces his father to confront the unintended consequences of his actions and the moral complexity of survival in a competitive environment.
Meanwhile, Natasha receives unexpected news from the immigration lawyer that provides a last-minute possibility for her family to remain in the United States. This development, while offering hope, also creates new uncertainty about her future and her relationship with Daniel. The possibility of staying forces her to reconsider her carefully constructed emotional defenses and confront what she truly wants for her future.
The novel's resolution is both hopeful and realistic, acknowledging that love alone cannot solve all problems while also affirming the transformative power of human connection. The final scenes between Daniel and Natasha capture the bittersweet nature of their situation – the joy of finding each other balanced against the uncertainty of their future together.
"Maybe part of falling in love with someone else is also falling in love with yourself."
The ending suggests that their single day together has fundamentally changed both characters, regardless of whether their romantic relationship continues. Natasha has learned to value emotional connection alongside intellectual understanding, while Daniel has developed a more nuanced view of love that encompasses both romantic idealism and practical reality. Their transformation demonstrates the novel's central argument that meaningful human connections can occur in any timeframe and that love's value is not diminished by its brevity or uncertainty.